The Problem with Overly Produced Content (And What Works Instead)

Most brands and creators assume more production = better content. They hire marketing agencies, overanalyze their audience, script every line, and spend thousands on professional video shoots.

Then they post it.

And nothing happens. Crickets.

Why? Because overly produced content is unrelatable—and on social media, relatability beats production every time.

Here’s why cinematic, high-budget content often flops and why candid, iPhone-shot content is dominating Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube.

---

What is Overly Produced Content?

Overly produced content is content that’s too professional, too polished, too scripted. It’s the kind of content that:

✔ Looks cinematic

✔ Feels calculated

✔ Has perfect lighting, perfect shots, perfect sound design

✔ Is backed by a marketing agency psychoanalyzing the audience

Sounds good, right? Wrong.

It assumes what the audience wants instead of actually showing them something real.

And the second you assume, you lose.

---

Why Overly Produced Content Fails

Overly produced content looks good but lacks connection.

It’s like watching a commercial. It’s polished, it’s beautiful, but you don’t feel anything.

People don’t go on social media to watch commercials. They go to be entertained, feel something, and relate to something.

Let’s say you’re trying to sell a teapot.

A corporate agency approach would look like this:

• A woman in a beautiful kitchen making tea.
• Soft music playing.
• A smooth voiceover talking about the craftsmanship of the teapot.

Sounds nice. But here’s what actually gets people’s attention:

A relatable approach would be:

• A guy trying to pour tea, and the lid gets stuck.
• The boiling water splashes on his hand—he jumps back, shaking his hand.
• Cut to: A quick shot of the new teapot design fixing the problem.

That’s real. That’s relatable. And that’s what works.

Because when someone sees that first three seconds, they immediately go:

“Damn, that happens to me too!”

And that’s when they engage.

---

Why iPhone Content Works Better

Social media is all about connection and speed.

Shooting quick, relatable content with your phone:

✅ Takes minutes, not hours

✅ Costs nothing (No production team, no expensive cameras)

✅ Feels natural and real (Not like an ad)

✅ Gets more engagement (Because it’s actually authentic)

That’s why TikTok, Instagram Reels, and YouTube Shorts are exploding. Nobody is sitting around watching high-budget, 2-minute commercials on social media. They want quick, engaging, relatable content filmed in real life.

---

Real-Life Example: When Cinematic Content Got Boring

Back in 2022, I was shooting ultra-cinematic real estate content.

I worked with brokers selling $10M+ penthouses in NYC and Miami. We made:

• Super cinematic, high-end walkthroughs
• Lifestyle shots of agents in luxury homes
• Drone shots flying through penthouses

And at first, it worked—because nobody else was doing it.

But within a year, everyone caught on. Drones got cheaper, luxury real estate content flooded the internet, and suddenly…

It wasn’t unique anymore.

The problem with overly produced trends is that they get overdone fast.

Now? People want real, candid behind-the-scenes content. They want to see the agent fumbling with the keys to a penthouse, showing a weird feature in a home, or reacting to an insane view in real time.

That’s what feels genuine.

---

Where Overly Produced Content Does Work

There is a time and place for high-budget, overly polished content:

✔ E-commerce product pages (Amazon listings, official websites)

✔ Brand commercials (For actual TV ads)

✔ Corporate marketing materials (Investor pitches, internal presentations)

But if you’re trying to grow on social media, you do not need Hollywood-level production.

Even if your brand is luxury, fashion, or high-end products, you can still shoot with your iPhone—but make it aesthetic.

---

The Smartest Strategy: Mix Both

The best brands and creators do this:

• Use cinematic content for ads, website, and official branding.
• Use casual, relatable content for social media engagement.

Look at big luxury brands on Instagram. Their ads are polished. Their social content is real, behind-the-scenes, and raw.

You should be doing the same.

---

How to Make Content That Actually Works

Instead of overproducing, do this:

1. Find Relatable Moments in Your Niche

Ask yourself:

• What small, annoying problems do people in my niche face?
• What funny, real-life moments happen all the time?
• What is something people in my audience will instantly connect with?

2. Shoot It With Your Phone

No expensive cameras. No fancy lights. Just grab your phone and shoot it naturally.

• If you’re selling a product, show a real-life struggle people have with it—then show how you solve it.
• If you’re a real estate agent, show the awkward reality of house showings, not just the luxury.
• If you’re a fitness coach, show what actually happens when people mess up workouts, not just the perfect form.

3. Keep It Under 30 Seconds

Attention spans are short. Your content should be quick, funny, engaging, and to the point.

If it takes more than a few seconds to hook someone, you’ve already lost them.

---

Final Thoughts: Skip the Overproduction, Go for Connection

Social media isn’t TV. People aren’t looking for movie-quality commercials. They want real, relatable, and fast-paced content that speaks directly to them.

Instead of spending hours scripting, shooting, and editing a “perfect” video, spend 10 minutes shooting something relatable on your phone.

You’ll get:

✔ More engagement

✔ More shares

✔ More growth

✔ Less wasted time and money

Skip the overly produced, over-scripted content. Make something real. That’s what wins in 2024.